From the Cheap Seats: A Case of Realignment Nerves - WVU Football, WVU Basketball, News - Mountaineer Sports

From the Cheap Seats: A Case of Realignment Nerves

Posted: Updated:

The Mountaineers are on the road for a couple of weeks, so we don't have to worry about filling Milan Puskar Stadium.  The lack of home games will allow us to go back to losing sleep over our conference future.            

The rampant speculation over what will happen to us has continued, but still, there's not much official information.  Unofficially, fans and university officials are nervous.            

The big question is, will that nervousness drive our decision making?  Since the realignment discussion began, our options have dwindled.  The ACC's been out for awhile.  Talk of the SEC has dropped to a low whisper.  That leaves the Big 12 and whatever becomes of the Big East.            

Until something, like Missouri finally making the jump to the SEC happens, we're looking at staying where we are.  So today, that's: us, Cincinnati, UCONN, Louisville, Rutgers, and South Florida.  "Reports" suggest that the Big East will invite Boise State, Southern Methodist, Houston, Central Florida, Air Force and Navy.  Would these additions excite you, as a fan?             

Boise State's obviously been a great program over the past decade or so.  It would be fun to see a game on their blue turf every few years.  If they were able to maintain their caliber of play, the Broncos would be our main challenge for a league championship each season.  It is a 2,000+ mile haul between Boise and Morgantown, but if they're just football members, it's not that big of a deal.            

SMU and Houston aren't exactly close to the rest of the Big East either, but they're in big cities that aren't bad trips by plane.  SMU is still trying to comeback from that NCAA "death penalty" it received in the ‘80s.  While it is in the Texas football hotbed, the school itself doesn't exactly fit in with the rest of the Big East members.            

Central Florida probably makes the most sense.  It's in another football hotbed, one that we already recruit heavily in.  Fans will travel to Orlando for the weather and Disney.  The best players in the Sunshine State will still go to Florida, Florida State and Miami and the second tier players would probably be spread out between the Golden Knights, South Florida, meaning we won't have to worry about either one challenging us year in and year out. 

Then there's Air Force and Navy.  Having the two best service academies in the league won't hurt.  West Virginia's high rate of military service gives us a lot in common.  Navy makes sense from a geographic standpoint.  Air Force is another outlier on the map, but Colorado offers enough reasons for fans to travel to every few years.  Expect the occasional, unexpected loss, due to their discipline and odd ball offenses.            

At the end of the day, the "new" Big East would be made up of 12 decent football programs, eight that make some regional sense and four others that probably bring enough to league to fit, even though they're outside of the region.              

Then, there's the Big 12 possibility.  Although I haven't been able to figure out how they fit, let's say more of these "reports" are right and the SEC takes Missouri.  "Reports" also say we're on the Big 12's short list.  Making another leap, if we're accepted, we'd join: Baylor, Iowa State, Kansas, Kansas State, Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Texas, Texas Tech and TCU.  Which one of these is not like the others?  The obvious answer is us.  The geography just does not make any sense.  We're having a hard time filling our own stadium and suddenly we're going to have thousands of fans trekking to Stillwater, Manhattan and other far-off cities you'd never think of visiting?  The idea has a certain novelty for our fans, and probably fans of the existing Big 12 schools, but you've got to think that would wear off fast, as the miles and airfare mounted.            

I want us to be an elite program as much as the next fan.  The Big 12 certainly has more traditional football powers than anything the Big East is going to come up with, but how much do we stand to gain from being in the Big 12?  Sure, we can be competitive in the league, but there's a difference between being competitive and being the odds on favorite to win the league every year, as we should be in the Big East.  The Big 12 typically has four to five teams ranked in the top 25, while the Big East is lucky to get two.  You stand a much better chance of continued success when you're one of two teams, instead of five.  I know our options are running out, but I hope a case of nerves doesn't have us forcing our square peg into a round conference hole.

  • More SportsMore>>

  • No. 7 Mountaineers Move On

    No. 7 Mountaineers Move On

    Saturday, November 18 2017 8:23 AM EST2017-11-18 13:23:09 GMT
    Rylee Foster and Nikki Izzo-Brown celebrate WVU's win in the second round of the NCAA Tournament.Rylee Foster and Nikki Izzo-Brown celebrate WVU's win in the second round of the NCAA Tournament.

    The No. 7 West Virginia University women's soccer team is moving on to the Sweet 16.

    The No. 7 West Virginia University women's soccer team is moving on to the Sweet 16.

  • 2018 Baseball Schedule Unveiled

    2018 Baseball Schedule Unveiled

    Thursday, November 16 2017 4:31 PM EST2017-11-16 21:31:39 GMT
    The WVU baseball team stands for the national anthem before a 4-2 win over Penn State at PNC Park. (PHOTO: Geoff Coyle)The WVU baseball team stands for the national anthem before a 4-2 win over Penn State at PNC Park. (PHOTO: Geoff Coyle)

    Highlighted by 23 home games and 21 games against teams that qualified for the NCAA Tournament in 2017, West Virginia University Director of Athletics Shane Lyons has announced the 2018 baseball schedule.

    Highlighted by 23 home games and 21 games against teams that qualified for the NCAA Tournament in 2017, West Virginia University Director of Athletics Shane Lyons has announced the 2018 baseball schedule.

  • WVU Topples Sacramento State

    WVU Topples Sacramento State

    Tuesday, November 14 2017 11:26 PM EST2017-11-15 04:26:00 GMT
    The WVU women's basketball team dominated Sacramento St. 101-47 on Tuesday.The WVU women's basketball team dominated Sacramento St. 101-47 on Tuesday.

    Teana Muldrow and Naomi Davenport each recorded a double-double for the second straight game as the No. 12/15 West Virginia University women’s basketball team dominated Sacramento State 101-47.

    Teana Muldrow and Naomi Davenport each recorded a double-double for the second straight game as the No. 12/15 West Virginia University women’s basketball team dominated Sacramento State 101-47.

  • FootballFootballMore>>

  • WVU Football Players and Assistants Talk Loss to Texas

    WVU Football Players and Assistants Talk Loss to Texas

    West Virginia Football Players and Assistant Coaches meet with the media to discuss WVU's loss to Texas at Mountaineer Field.

    West Virginia Football Players and Assistant Coaches meet with the media to discuss WVU's loss to Texas at Mountaineer Field.

  • WVU Football Coach Holgorsen Talks Texas Loss

    WVU Football Coach Holgorsen Talks Texas Loss

    Dana Holgorsen and the Mountaineers will host No. 10 Oklahoma State at noon on Oct. 28. (PHOTO: Scott Lituchy)Dana Holgorsen and the Mountaineers will host No. 10 Oklahoma State at noon on Oct. 28. (PHOTO: Scott Lituchy)
    West Virginia Football Head Coach Dana Holgorsen addresses the media regarding the Mountaineers' loss to Texas in Morgantown.
    West Virginia Football Head Coach Dana Holgorsen addresses the media regarding the Mountaineers' loss to Texas in Morgantown.
  • Game Recap: Texas Spoils WVU Senior Day

    Game Recap: Texas Spoils WVU Senior Day

     Freshman safety Kenny Robinson has made some big plays over the last few weeks. None may be bigger than the play he made Saturday. Robinson’s interception and return for a touchdown brought life back into Milan Puskar Stadium and back to the West Virginia (7-4, 5-3) sideline that had not been present since a gruesome hand injury to quarterback Will Grier earlier in the game.

     Freshman safety Kenny Robinson has made some big plays over the last few weeks. None may be bigger than the play he made Saturday. Robinson’s interception and return for a touchdown brought life back into Milan Puskar Stadium and back to the West Virginia (7-4, 5-3) sideline that had not been present since a gruesome hand injury to quarterback Will Grier earlier in the game.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Game Recap: Miles, WVU dominates Morgan State

    Game Recap: Miles, WVU dominates Morgan State

    Saturday, November 18 2017 10:14 PM EST2017-11-19 03:14:49 GMT

     No. 24 West Virginia (2-1) hadn’t gotten off to the greatest starts in either of its first two games of the regular season. Third time’s the charm, as they say. After trailing 3-2 in the opening minute of the game, the Mountaineers jumped out to nearly a forty-point lead by halftime en route to a 111-48 win over Morgan State (2-2) Saturday evening inside the Coliseum.

     No. 24 West Virginia (2-1) hadn’t gotten off to the greatest starts in either of its first two games of the regular season. Third time’s the charm, as they say. After trailing 3-2 in the opening minute of the game, the Mountaineers jumped out to nearly a forty-point lead by halftime en route to a 111-48 win over Morgan State (2-2) Saturday evening inside the Coliseum.

  • WVU Football Players and Assistants Talk Loss to Texas

    WVU Football Players and Assistants Talk Loss to Texas

    West Virginia Football Players and Assistant Coaches meet with the media to discuss WVU's loss to Texas at Mountaineer Field.

    West Virginia Football Players and Assistant Coaches meet with the media to discuss WVU's loss to Texas at Mountaineer Field.

  • Game Recap: Texas Spoils WVU Senior Day

    Game Recap: Texas Spoils WVU Senior Day

     Freshman safety Kenny Robinson has made some big plays over the last few weeks. None may be bigger than the play he made Saturday. Robinson’s interception and return for a touchdown brought life back into Milan Puskar Stadium and back to the West Virginia (7-4, 5-3) sideline that had not been present since a gruesome hand injury to quarterback Will Grier earlier in the game.

     Freshman safety Kenny Robinson has made some big plays over the last few weeks. None may be bigger than the play he made Saturday. Robinson’s interception and return for a touchdown brought life back into Milan Puskar Stadium and back to the West Virginia (7-4, 5-3) sideline that had not been present since a gruesome hand injury to quarterback Will Grier earlier in the game.

  • WVU Football Coach Holgorsen Talks Texas Loss

    WVU Football Coach Holgorsen Talks Texas Loss

    Dana Holgorsen and the Mountaineers will host No. 10 Oklahoma State at noon on Oct. 28. (PHOTO: Scott Lituchy)Dana Holgorsen and the Mountaineers will host No. 10 Oklahoma State at noon on Oct. 28. (PHOTO: Scott Lituchy)
    West Virginia Football Head Coach Dana Holgorsen addresses the media regarding the Mountaineers' loss to Texas in Morgantown.
    West Virginia Football Head Coach Dana Holgorsen addresses the media regarding the Mountaineers' loss to Texas in Morgantown.
  • Game Preview: WVU Hoops host Morgan State

    Game Preview: WVU Hoops host Morgan State

    WVU senior guard Jevon Carter and the Mountaineers are picked to finish 2nd in the Big 12 Preseason Poll. (PHOTO: Geoff Coyle)WVU senior guard Jevon Carter and the Mountaineers are picked to finish 2nd in the Big 12 Preseason Poll. (PHOTO: Geoff Coyle)
    By Ryan Decker No. 24 West Virginia (1-1) plays its first of two games heading into Thanksgiving break Saturday evening against Morgan State (2-1). The Mountaineers most recent outing – a 34-point win over American on Wednesday – was much more successful than their first of the year. Morgan State, winner of two games in a row, has also played better as of late and is coming off a 12-point win Thursday. Five WVU players are averaging double-figure scoring totals this ...
    By Ryan Decker No. 24 West Virginia (1-1) plays its first of two games heading into Thanksgiving break Saturday evening against Morgan State (2-1). The Mountaineers most recent outing – a 34-point win over American on Wednesday – was much more successful than their first of the year. Morgan State, winner of two games in a row, has also played better as of late and is coming off a 12-point win Thursday. Five WVU players are averaging double-figure scoring totals this ...
  • Dana Holgorsen's Postgame News Conference LIVE on WVi

    Dana Holgorsen's Postgame News Conference LIVE on WVi

    WVi will be streaming Dana Holgorsen's Postgame News Conferences LIVE following each home game throughout the season. It all begins with the opener against Marshall.
  • No. 7 Mountaineers Move On

    No. 7 Mountaineers Move On

    Saturday, November 18 2017 8:23 AM EST2017-11-18 13:23:09 GMT
    Rylee Foster and Nikki Izzo-Brown celebrate WVU's win in the second round of the NCAA Tournament.Rylee Foster and Nikki Izzo-Brown celebrate WVU's win in the second round of the NCAA Tournament.

    The No. 7 West Virginia University women's soccer team is moving on to the Sweet 16.

    The No. 7 West Virginia University women's soccer team is moving on to the Sweet 16.

  • 2017-18 WVU Men’s Basketball Schedule

    2017-18 WVU Men’s Basketball Schedule

    Bob Huggins looks on as the Mountaineers practice at the SAP Center in San Jose. (PHOTO: Geoff Coyle)Bob Huggins looks on as the Mountaineers practice at the SAP Center in San Jose. (PHOTO: Geoff Coyle)

    MORGANTOWN, W.Va. (August 31, 2017) – West Virginia University Director of Athletics Shane Lyons and the Big 12 Conference have announced the 2017-18 men’s basketball schedule. 

    MORGANTOWN, W.Va. (August 31, 2017) – West Virginia University Director of Athletics Shane Lyons and the Big 12 Conference have announced the 2017-18 men’s basketball schedule.