From the Cheap Seats: Why Aren't There More Mountaineers in the - WVU Football, WVU Basketball, News - Mountaineer Sports

From the Cheap Seats: Why Aren't There More Mountaineers in the NFL

Posted: Updated:

Watching the Super Bowl a few weeks ago, I was struck by a question I've asked myself many times: Why aren't there more Mountaineers in the NFL? As I watched three players who fell to the Mountaineers in college, Eli Manning, Ahmad Bradshaw and Hakeem Nicks, lead the Giants to the championship, a new question popped into my head: How many other pro players lost to WVU during their college days? With that question in mind, I set off to do some non-scientific research(translation: I probably missed a couple of guys). I was pretty amazed by what I found.

To start with, there are 15 former ‘Eers in the league, but there are 249 players on current NFL rosters who felt the sting of defeat at the hands of the Mountaineers during their college careers. Combined, those players lost 490 times to West Virginia. Among that group are 13 2012 Pro Bowlers and seven quarterbacks who started at least one NFL game this season(Tyler Palko? Really?). For every Manning, Ray Rice or Larry Fitzgerald, there are a dozen guys you've probably never heard of. All 32 NFL teams feature at least three players who lost to the Mountaineers, only four clubs have fewer than five, and eight teams have more than 10. The Colts lead the way with 19. Pat McAfee certainly has bragging rights in that locker room.

I wasn't too surprised to find that 17 Oklahoma players from the 2008 Fiesta Bowl or nine members of the 2006 Georgia Bulldogs Sugar Bowl team are in the pros. Those teams are from the power conferences that are supposed to produce NFL talent. I was a little surprised to find that the North Carolina team we beat in the 2008 Car Care Bowl sent 15 players to the league.

What really surprised me is the number of players from Big East rivals who've gone pro. Rutgers(23), Pitt(22) and Syracuse(17), all have more NFL guys who lost to us, than we have total. The former Scarlet Knights alone have lost 87 times to WVU. They haven't been able to beat us since 1994, but they can apparently churn out NFL players. I can't imagine that it's something in the Jersey water.

Stepping out of conference, Maryland is another bit of a head-scratcher. We've owned them since 2004, but somehow 26 Terrapins who fell at the hands of the Mountaineers have made it professionally. Keep in mind that I'm only talking about players whose college teams lost to WVU. There are dozens more NFLers whose teams defeated the Mountaineers.

I hate to say it, but the former Mountaineers who are currently in the NFL, aren't exactly lighting the world on fire. It hasn't always been like this. In Don Nehlen's 20 years at the helm, he sent more than 70 players to the NFL and 27 of them had careers of five seasons or longer.

So why aren't there more WVU players in the pros? I guess I don't know enough about the NFL to have that answer. We've haven't had the biggest guys over the past decade, so does it boil down to simple physical size? Injury has certainly played a part. Injuries quickly ended the pro careers of guys like Grant Wiley, who based on their college exploits, seemed sure to excel in the NFL.

It's certainly not from a lack of competition. As described above, the Mountaineers face plenty of next-level players during their careers in Morgantown. That's why it's so frustrating. Our players can obviously compete with these guys on the college field, why not is the pros?

It's obviously not correlated to on-the-field success. No matter how you feel about them, over the last decade, the trio of Rich Rodriguez, Bill Stewart and Dana Holgorsen, have led the Gold and Blue to 95 wins and the school's only three major bowl victories. I wouldn't trade any of WVU's victories for a former Mountaineer's success in the NFL, but it sure would make pro football more appealing than watching a bunch of guys who lost to WVU play against each other.

Bruce Irvin and Najee Goode are taking part in the NFL Combine right now. Time will tell if they can make a mark on the league. Why do you think more Mountaineers haven't done well at the next level? Which player's lack of success in the pros has surprised you the most? Major Harris and Pat White come to my mind right away. Share your thoughts by commenting below.

  • More SportsMore>>

  • Tough Match Halts No. 7 WVU's Run

    Tough Match Halts No. 7 WVU's Run

    Sunday, November 19 2017 8:43 PM EST2017-11-20 01:43:27 GMT
    Grace Cutler and Carla Portillo share a hug after WVU's Sweet 16 loss to Penn St.Grace Cutler and Carla Portillo share a hug after WVU's Sweet 16 loss to Penn St.

    The No. 7-ranked and second-seeded WVU women's soccer team came up short this evening its quest for a third straight trip to the NCAA Tournament quarterfinals.

    The No. 7-ranked and second-seeded WVU women's soccer team came up short this evening its quest for a third straight trip to the NCAA Tournament quarterfinals.

  • No. 7 Mountaineers Move On

    No. 7 Mountaineers Move On

    Saturday, November 18 2017 8:23 AM EST2017-11-18 13:23:09 GMT
    Rylee Foster and Nikki Izzo-Brown celebrate WVU's win in the second round of the NCAA Tournament.Rylee Foster and Nikki Izzo-Brown celebrate WVU's win in the second round of the NCAA Tournament.

    The No. 7 West Virginia University women's soccer team is moving on to the Sweet 16.

    The No. 7 West Virginia University women's soccer team is moving on to the Sweet 16.

  • 2018 Baseball Schedule Unveiled

    2018 Baseball Schedule Unveiled

    Thursday, November 16 2017 4:31 PM EST2017-11-16 21:31:39 GMT
    The WVU baseball team stands for the national anthem before a 4-2 win over Penn State at PNC Park. (PHOTO: Geoff Coyle)The WVU baseball team stands for the national anthem before a 4-2 win over Penn State at PNC Park. (PHOTO: Geoff Coyle)

    Highlighted by 23 home games and 21 games against teams that qualified for the NCAA Tournament in 2017, West Virginia University Director of Athletics Shane Lyons has announced the 2018 baseball schedule.

    Highlighted by 23 home games and 21 games against teams that qualified for the NCAA Tournament in 2017, West Virginia University Director of Athletics Shane Lyons has announced the 2018 baseball schedule.

  • FootballFootballMore>>

  • WVU Football Players and Assistants Talk Loss to Texas

    WVU Football Players and Assistants Talk Loss to Texas

    West Virginia Football Players and Assistant Coaches meet with the media to discuss WVU's loss to Texas at Mountaineer Field.

    West Virginia Football Players and Assistant Coaches meet with the media to discuss WVU's loss to Texas at Mountaineer Field.

  • WVU Football Coach Holgorsen Talks Texas Loss

    WVU Football Coach Holgorsen Talks Texas Loss

    Dana Holgorsen and the Mountaineers will host No. 10 Oklahoma State at noon on Oct. 28. (PHOTO: Scott Lituchy)Dana Holgorsen and the Mountaineers will host No. 10 Oklahoma State at noon on Oct. 28. (PHOTO: Scott Lituchy)
    West Virginia Football Head Coach Dana Holgorsen addresses the media regarding the Mountaineers' loss to Texas in Morgantown.
    West Virginia Football Head Coach Dana Holgorsen addresses the media regarding the Mountaineers' loss to Texas in Morgantown.
  • Game Recap: Texas Spoils WVU Senior Day

    Game Recap: Texas Spoils WVU Senior Day

     Freshman safety Kenny Robinson has made some big plays over the last few weeks. None may be bigger than the play he made Saturday. Robinson’s interception and return for a touchdown brought life back into Milan Puskar Stadium and back to the West Virginia (7-4, 5-3) sideline that had not been present since a gruesome hand injury to quarterback Will Grier earlier in the game.

     Freshman safety Kenny Robinson has made some big plays over the last few weeks. None may be bigger than the play he made Saturday. Robinson’s interception and return for a touchdown brought life back into Milan Puskar Stadium and back to the West Virginia (7-4, 5-3) sideline that had not been present since a gruesome hand injury to quarterback Will Grier earlier in the game.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Game Recap: Miles, WVU dominates Morgan State

    Game Recap: Miles, WVU dominates Morgan State

    Saturday, November 18 2017 10:14 PM EST2017-11-19 03:14:49 GMT

     No. 24 West Virginia (2-1) hadn’t gotten off to the greatest starts in either of its first two games of the regular season. Third time’s the charm, as they say. After trailing 3-2 in the opening minute of the game, the Mountaineers jumped out to nearly a forty-point lead by halftime en route to a 111-48 win over Morgan State (2-2) Saturday evening inside the Coliseum.

     No. 24 West Virginia (2-1) hadn’t gotten off to the greatest starts in either of its first two games of the regular season. Third time’s the charm, as they say. After trailing 3-2 in the opening minute of the game, the Mountaineers jumped out to nearly a forty-point lead by halftime en route to a 111-48 win over Morgan State (2-2) Saturday evening inside the Coliseum.

  • Pardee’s Career Night Helps WVU Past UNF

    Pardee’s Career Night Helps WVU Past UNF

    Sunday, November 19 2017 10:13 PM EST2017-11-20 03:13:38 GMT
    The WVU women's basketball team advances to the second round of the NCAA Tournament with a 75-62 win over Elon. (PHOTO: Anjelica Trinone)The WVU women's basketball team advances to the second round of the NCAA Tournament with a 75-62 win over Elon. (PHOTO: Anjelica Trinone)

    The WVU women's basketball team is now 3-0 after a 89-57 victory over North Florida on Sunday.

    The WVU women's basketball team is now 3-0 after a 89-57 victory over North Florida on Sunday.

  • WVU Football Players and Assistants Talk Loss to Texas

    WVU Football Players and Assistants Talk Loss to Texas

    West Virginia Football Players and Assistant Coaches meet with the media to discuss WVU's loss to Texas at Mountaineer Field.

    West Virginia Football Players and Assistant Coaches meet with the media to discuss WVU's loss to Texas at Mountaineer Field.

  • WVi Has Moved!

    WVi Has Moved!

    Friday, September 2 2011 1:45 PM EDT2011-09-02 17:45:05 GMT
    Don't worry, wvillustrated.com is still alive and well. WVi has upgraded to a brand new and improved website. Please check out http://www.wvillustrated.com/ We hope you enjoy the new WVi experience.
  • Game Preview: WVU Hoops host Morgan State

    Game Preview: WVU Hoops host Morgan State

    WVU senior guard Jevon Carter and the Mountaineers are picked to finish 2nd in the Big 12 Preseason Poll. (PHOTO: Geoff Coyle)WVU senior guard Jevon Carter and the Mountaineers are picked to finish 2nd in the Big 12 Preseason Poll. (PHOTO: Geoff Coyle)
    By Ryan Decker No. 24 West Virginia (1-1) plays its first of two games heading into Thanksgiving break Saturday evening against Morgan State (2-1). The Mountaineers most recent outing – a 34-point win over American on Wednesday – was much more successful than their first of the year. Morgan State, winner of two games in a row, has also played better as of late and is coming off a 12-point win Thursday. Five WVU players are averaging double-figure scoring totals this ...
    By Ryan Decker No. 24 West Virginia (1-1) plays its first of two games heading into Thanksgiving break Saturday evening against Morgan State (2-1). The Mountaineers most recent outing – a 34-point win over American on Wednesday – was much more successful than their first of the year. Morgan State, winner of two games in a row, has also played better as of late and is coming off a 12-point win Thursday. Five WVU players are averaging double-figure scoring totals this ...
  • WVU Football Coach Holgorsen Talks Texas Loss

    WVU Football Coach Holgorsen Talks Texas Loss

    Dana Holgorsen and the Mountaineers will host No. 10 Oklahoma State at noon on Oct. 28. (PHOTO: Scott Lituchy)Dana Holgorsen and the Mountaineers will host No. 10 Oklahoma State at noon on Oct. 28. (PHOTO: Scott Lituchy)
    West Virginia Football Head Coach Dana Holgorsen addresses the media regarding the Mountaineers' loss to Texas in Morgantown.
    West Virginia Football Head Coach Dana Holgorsen addresses the media regarding the Mountaineers' loss to Texas in Morgantown.
  • Has West Virginia Found a Rival?

    Has West Virginia Found a Rival?

    Wednesday, March 27 2013 1:06 PM EDT2013-03-27 17:06:06 GMT
    When you think of a current rivalry involving the Mountaineers, it may be hard to think of their opponent. Sure, there will always be Pitt, and perhaps Marshall, but as the years go on, these rivalries
    Nearly a full year into the Big 12 Conference, the Mountaineers are still looking for a rivalry similar to those from the past.
  • Game Recap: Texas Spoils WVU Senior Day

    Game Recap: Texas Spoils WVU Senior Day

     Freshman safety Kenny Robinson has made some big plays over the last few weeks. None may be bigger than the play he made Saturday. Robinson’s interception and return for a touchdown brought life back into Milan Puskar Stadium and back to the West Virginia (7-4, 5-3) sideline that had not been present since a gruesome hand injury to quarterback Will Grier earlier in the game.

     Freshman safety Kenny Robinson has made some big plays over the last few weeks. None may be bigger than the play he made Saturday. Robinson’s interception and return for a touchdown brought life back into Milan Puskar Stadium and back to the West Virginia (7-4, 5-3) sideline that had not been present since a gruesome hand injury to quarterback Will Grier earlier in the game.